Whether it’s for birthday party favor bags or team treat bags, these items are sure to be a hit—pun intended! 🙂
We’ve made treat bags for everything from Halloween and Easter to the World Series and beyond, so we’re always on the lookout for fresh, fun ideas. These picks are perfect for players and siblings alike, and they add a little extra excitement to any celebration or game day.
Eye Stick
These eye black stickers are a must-have to help keep the sun out of your player’s eyes during games and practices. And the best part? Players love getting creative with their designs—crosses, triangles, initials, and more. It’s functional, fun, and adds a little personality to their game-day look!
Banana Keychains
Blame it on the Savannah Bananas™, but to me, bananas and baseball now go hand in hand.
These banana-themed keychains are a fun little gift your player will love! They’re perfect for clipping onto a baseball bag, school backpack, or key set—a playful reminder of the game they love, with a nod to the team that made baseball even more fun.
Juicy Fruit Snacks
These are the (slightly) healthier version of my son’s all-time favorite snack—Gushers™. Packed with fruity flavor and a satisfying texture, they’re a hit in our house. In fact, my son and husband love them so much, they could easily polish off a whole box in a day!
Rebound Balls on String
These are a huge hit with players of all ages—and yes, I mean all ages!
Whether it’s the big kids on the field or the little siblings on the sidelines, these are a fun way to keep everyone entertained during the game. They’re easy to use, endlessly fun, and a great way to keep the energy high while the innings roll on.
Water Bottles
A little splurge—but totally worth it!
These are a bit more expensive than what I’d usually spend on a favor or gift bag item, but if you split the cost with another sports mom, they’re perfect! Plus, if you’re the crafty type, you can even customize them with player names or numbers for a personal touch that makes them extra special.
Sports Drink
You really can’t go wrong with a sports drink—it’s something your player will definitely use.
If you can find the newest flavor to try, you’ll instantly earn cool points as the ultimate sports mom! Just a quick tip: check the label before buying, as some varieties contain caffeine or energy-boosting ingredients that may not be suitable for younger players.
Jerky Snack
Every athlete needs protein in their diet—and these individually wrapped snacks are perfect for that!
They’re convenient, mess-free, and ideal for tossing into a baseball bag or lunchbox. Maybe it’s the Texas in us, but my son’s favorite is the jalapeño flavor—a little kick that keeps him coming back for more!
Big League Chew
Peanuts, Cracker Jacks, and Big League Chew—can you get more classic than that?
These individual packs are perfect for slipping into a bag pocket for game day.
Stickers
Drink bottles, notebooks, phone cases, helmets—the options for placing stickers are endless!
Stickers are a fun and easy way to show your love for the sport anywhere. Whether you’re decorating gear, personalizing school supplies, or adding flair to your game-day essentials, they’re a hit with players and fans alike.
Cooling Towels
If you live and play anywhere hot (hello, Texas!), these are a must-have.
Cooling towels are a game-day lifesaver. Players can wear them around their necks or wrap them around their heads like little ninjas to stay cool in the heat. They’re also a total win for parents and coaches on the sidelines. One of our team moms even customized them with names and numbers—super cute and super helpful for keeping track of whose is whose!
Shoe Charms
Shoe charms are a hit with players of all ages—and moms too!
(Confession: I’ve definitely snagged a few from my son’s goodie bags for my own shoes—shhh! 😉)
This bulk option includes a large count of random charms, which is great for favor bags. You can also opt for a smaller pack with known designs if you’re looking for something specific. The random packs may include duplicates, but that just adds to the fun and makes trading or twinning easy!
Cloth Necklace
Athletes have their own unique style—and necklaces are one way they love to express it.
These particular necklaces are soft, comfy, and non-irritating, making them perfect for all-day wear, even during games and practices.
Bling Necklace
If your athlete loves the bling like the big leaguers, these are a home run! Available in a variety of colors, they’re a stylish way to show off team pride or sport your favorite team’s colors. Whether on the field or cheering from the sidelines, they add a bold pop of personality and flair!
Cracker Jack
The perfect classic snack—save it for the 7th inning stretch!
Toss a few individual packs into your player’s bag or treat bags for the team—they’re always a hit and never go out of style.
